Sunday 10 February 2013

Battle of the Bargain Eyeshadow Primers- Elf v MUA

cream tube and black tube on floral quilt
spoolie brush with cream liquid
white fingers with lilac painted fingernails holding cream tube and spoolie brush
fingers holding black tube and spoolie brush from tube
blurred close up of spoolie brush with cream liquid
Hey Everyone!

You may know that I have a lot of trouble trying to keep my eye makeup on all day- from eyeshadow creasing to mascara smudging, the problems are endless. A few months ago I ordered elf's eyelid primer (£1.50) and for Christmas I got the MUA Professional Eyes Primer (£2.50). I'm sure you will agree that if nothing else, you certainly get a good price on these products.

In terms of packaging, I prefer MUA as I think it has a slightly higher quality feel, whereas the elf primer comes in the boggest of bog standard tubes. The applicators are very similar, if not identical. I find the formula of the MUA to be slightly 'wetter' and it goes further than the elf. Both provide a smooth, sheer base for my eyeshadow which I like texture-wise. However, neither primer ensures a crease free day! I would say MUA primer has a slightly longer lasting power, but essentially, neither will last more than a few hours. In all honesty, I think the products are very, very similar, perhaps even from the same retailer with different packaging. 

Neither works wonders, yet neither is an awful product. I will continue to use both as they do provide a nice even base for eyeshadow.

My favour leans slightly towards MUA, despite the fact its more expensive, I think it does the job a little more effectively and will last longer. For the price, I would at least give it a try!
green and pink floral text with brown outline reading 'Julz'

4 comments:

  1. I think I'm going to try the MUA one, I got a sample size of the UDPP with my naked palette but I can't afford to replace it :/ x

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If you do let me know how you get on! I really want the naked palette :P xx

      Delete